This article first appeared in the Hindu on June 19.
What does the cancellation of Class 12 board exam mean for students? And what can the CBSE do to ensure a fair assessment of a student’s overall performance?
“Hey dude, what is Newton’s Second Law?”
“I’m a Science student; not a Law student”
“Ah! COVID batch!”
This is both funny and harsh, but memes apart, it’s tough being the Covid Batch. First, just spending your last school year at home missing out on the bossing around, the making and breaking of rules and history, and the leadership opportunities you have worked for. Then there was the endless wait for the board exams to be rescheduled and, finally, the cancellation.
Not that there was any alternative. “Not doing the Class 12 boards is one of the best decisions we have made,” says Rekha Krishnan, Principal of Vasant Valley School in Delhi, “else this would have been another super-spreader event.”
But what are the implications of this for the students?
Class 12 results formula
Last week, the CBSE declared its 30:30:40 formula as an “objective system” of arriving at the Class 12 results. Here is a quick analysis of what works — and what doesn’t — in this formula.
Problem 1: Any weightage given to Class 10 scores is unfair to students whose performance increased dramatically after those board exams when they chose subjects they liked and dropped those that didn’t work for them. “It is wrong to reward or punish a child on the same performance twice, “ says Krishnan. Why should a kid who messed up Class X boards suffer a poor grade in Class 12 because of that?
Problem 2: Grade 11 scores are often not representative since students are dealing with a giant leap in conceptual difficulty in some subjects like Science, and with totally new concepts in other subjects like Sociology, Psychology and Accounts. “The data we have shows that, on an average, a student’s marks make a leap of around 20–25% over their Class 11 scores,” says Vishnu Karthik, director of The Heritage Group of Schools. The worst part is that several students take Class 11 lightly, knowing that these grades don’t count. Giving these marks 30% weightage without any warning seems unfair.
Problem 3: Inconsistent internal scores across schools and potential grade inflation. “Unlike international curricula, CBSE schools aren’t subjected to rigorous assessment audits and statistical moderations. Just look at the inordinate high grades students achieve in Class 12 internal practical exams,” points out Karthik.
On another note, since internal exams were not pitched as final assessments, many schools followed the standard practice of tough papers with strict marking schemes. “Most schools like to challenge their students and train them by setting exams more difficult than the typical board exam. Further, most students put in their best efforts a couple of months before the final board exams. As a result, historical data shows that the performance is significantly better in the board exams than in the internal school exams,” says Sanghamitra Ghosh, former principal of Mother’s International School.
The saving grace
CBSE’s master stroke to balance these issues out is using a historical reference to anchor these scores. This means that the school must roughly map its current scores to its previous Class 12 scores in whichever of the last three years’ board exams it performed best. “For each subject, the school will have to follow a broad distribution of marks, which will be based on the performance of the specific year by that school in that subject. The subject-wise marks assessed by the school for 2020-2021 should be within a range of +/- 5 marks obtained by the students in the school in the subject in the reference year. However, the overall average marks for the school assessed in 2020-2021, for all the subjects, should not exceed the overall average marks obtained by the school by two marks in the specific reference year,” states the tabulation policy.
This process makes it possible for the newly constituted “result committees” in each school to use internal grades to map student performance relative to each other and then use the historical anchors to scale the final results to board-level marks. What could make this system fairer is to reduce the dependence on Class 10 scores by allowing schools to take a “best of three” subjects from Class 10, including any continuing subjects like English.
Impact on college admissions
Conditional admissions abroad: Many students have received “conditional” admissions from colleges in the U.K. and Canada, subject to achieving a certain aggregate percentage in their boards. Predictably, though, foreign universities have reassured students that they will be “flexible” in handling any delay in declaring results. For the U.K. universities, the UCAS suggests on its official page, “If you have a conditional firm/insurance set already, the University would have until around the September 14, 2021” to close their offers. Most universities will use this wide window to give student time to share their final grades. The delay will impact their visa processes, though, and some students may end up doing their first college month/semester online though colleges in the U.K. have started on-campus classes. Most Canadian universities have gone a step further in processing the “conditions” of their admission offers by suggesting that conditional admissions would be revoked only in case of a “drastic” fall in grades. “We recognise that students in India are unable to complete board exams,” says Bianca Tuazon, recruiter from the University of British Columbia. “The university will no longer require final Class 12 exam results. Instead, we have confirmed students’ offer using their pre-board results or marksheets, and have issued new offer letter with conditions removed.”
Cut-off based college admissions in India: Most national and state universities like Delhi University, Kolkata University and Mumbai University use Class 12 marks for admissions. A Central Universities Common Entrance Test (CUCET) is being considered to replace this dependence on board marks. The CUCET committee has submitted its report to the Education Ministry but a decision is pending. If a CUCET is conducted for this batch, it will be tough with no past tests and results to be guided by. Students already exhausted by the long wait for the boards will now need to switch energies to a new testing system. But at least it will provide a common platform for all students to be judged on.
What this means for future CBSE batches
These two years have exposed the weakness of a board-exam system quite clearly. “The boards place undue weightage on one exam so that students are not bothered about internal exam results and everyone — colleges, parents, even distant family members — want to know the Class 12 board results,” says Krishnan. International curricula like IGCSE and IB, on the other hand, offer numerous formative assessments over Classes 11 and 12 that allow a student to study steadily and even out any “bad luck” performance in one exam. Their final results, thus, provides a fairer prediction of a student’s academic potential than one single board exam. But, as Karthik points out, “Unlike other international curricula, the CBSE has not invested in valid and reliable internal year-round assessment. In the CBSE, there is not much correlation between internal and final external exams.” Perhaps this is a wake-up call to invest in a system of internal assessment and audits that leads to a fair assessment of a student’s overall performance and reduce the pressure at the end of the school year.
Finally, to return to the meme at the beginning. Is this really going to be a poorly educated batch? One with less knowledge gleaned from online classes and a botched-up assessment system? Krishnan disagrees, “These students have a huge advantage over others. They have almost been through a trial by fire, learning to constantly respond to life. Today, you can find Newton’s Second Law from Google but the life lessons this kind of experience gives them far outweighs their losses in learning static concepts.”
If the COVID batch is ready to face the fire, then the CBSE should give them the best starting point by mapping this years’ results to good results in previous batches; by allowing those with the stamina to study to take alternative exams to better their scores; by encouraging universities to conduct a simple CUCET that tests skills rather than knowledge. And, perhaps, by rethinking the whole system of assessments for the batches to come.
Richa Dwivedi Saklani is a certified coach from UCLA and is an accredited MBTI trainer who has worked with over 10,000 people across career planning and as a behavioral trainer in companies. She is the CEO & Founder of Inomi Learning and author of “The Ultimate Guide to 21st Century Careers”.
トルソー ラブドール I got what you intend, regards for posting. Woh I am happy to find this website through google. Engaging in sexual intercourse with a jy doll has nothing to do with tr
Wow, superb weblog layout! How lengthy have you been blogging for?
you made blogging look easy. The total glance of your
website is wonderful, as smartly as the content material!
You can see similar here e-commerce
india pharmacy http://indiaph24.store/# cheapest online pharmacy india
reputable indian pharmacies
https://indiaph24.store/# online shopping pharmacy india
india pharmacy reputable indian pharmacies indian pharmacy paypal
mexican pharmacy: pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
top online pharmacy india https://indiaph24.store/# top 10 pharmacies in india
Online medicine home delivery
buy cytotec pills: buy misoprostol over the counter – cytotec online
https://lisinopril.network/# website
buy generic ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin generic price buy cipro online
natural alternatives to tamoxifen: where to get nolvadex – nolvadex estrogen blocker
http://nolvadex.life/# aromatase inhibitor tamoxifen
http://lisinopril.network/# lisinopril without rx
tamoxifen 20 mg tamoxifen and antidepressants how does tamoxifen work
propecia tablets: get cheap propecia tablets – buying generic propecia without rx
ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price buy cipro online canada buy cipro online canada
https://cytotec.club/# buy cytotec over the counter
https://cytotec.club/# Cytotec 200mcg price
nolvadex online tamoxifen for sale alternatives to tamoxifen
ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price: cipro generic – ciprofloxacin
http://nolvadex.life/# should i take tamoxifen
https://finasteride.store/# buying generic propecia
cost cheap propecia without insurance cost of propecia for sale generic propecia no prescription
Cytotec 200mcg price buy cytotec online fast delivery cytotec abortion pill
http://lisinopril.network/# lisinopril 10mg tablets price
tamoxifen medication: buy tamoxifen – tamoxifen and uterine thickening
http://cytotec.club/# п»їcytotec pills online
cost of cheap propecia online: get propecia online – get generic propecia without dr prescription
http://cytotec.club/# buy cytotec over the counter
purchase cytotec purchase cytotec buy cytotec pills
lisinopril 1 mg tablet: lisinopril 3972 – lisinopril 5 mg prices
http://ciprofloxacin.tech/# antibiotics cipro
http://ciprofloxacin.tech/# ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online
common side effects of tamoxifen how to get nolvadex nolvadex steroids
cipro pharmacy cipro cipro online no prescription in the usa
get generic propecia without dr prescription cheap propecia without a prescription or order generic propecia
https://toolbarqueries.google.ki/url?sa=t&url=https://finasteride.store cost cheap propecia prices
buy cheap propecia online order propecia pills and buy propecia without rx buying cheap propecia without a prescription
cytotec online purchase cytotec or buy cytotec online fast delivery
http://www.a-31.de/url?q=https://cytotec.club buy cytotec pills online cheap
cytotec buy online usa buy cytotec online fast delivery and purchase cytotec buy cytotec over the counter
http://finasteride.store/# cost of propecia without a prescription
buy cytotec: cytotec online – purchase cytotec
nolvadex pills tamoxifen hip pain nolvadex 20mg
http://nolvadex.life/# nolvadex 20mg
Cytotec 200mcg price buy cytotec in usa cytotec pills buy online
cost of generic propecia price: buy propecia no prescription – get propecia tablets
https://cytotec.club/# buy misoprostol over the counter
generic propecia prices: buying cheap propecia without insurance – order cheap propecia pills
http://lisinopril.network/# medication lisinopril 5 mg
buying propecia tablets cost of cheap propecia price buying cheap propecia no prescription
tamoxifen citrate pct tamoxifen benefits or tamoxifen chemo
https://www.steinhaus-gmbh.de/redirect.php?lang=en&url=https://nolvadex.life how to lose weight on tamoxifen
tamoxifen estrogen tamoxifen for men and nolvadex generic where to buy nolvadex
lisinopril 5 mg tablet price: lisinopril 10 mg brand name in india – lisinopril 20 mg pill
https://nolvadex.life/# nolvadex d
https://finasteride.store/# get cheap propecia without a prescription
buying propecia tablets get propecia without insurance or cheap propecia price
http://crewe.de/url?q=https://finasteride.store propecia buy
buy generic propecia pill buy cheap propecia prices and generic propecia without rx order propecia tablets
buy cytotec over the counter п»їcytotec pills online buy misoprostol over the counter
nolvadex for pct: tamoxifen dosage – tamoxifen hip pain
http://nolvadex.life/# nolvadex price
propecia pill generic propecia online cost generic propecia without prescription
http://nolvadex.life/# generic tamoxifen
cipro cipro 500mg best prices buy ciprofloxacin tablets
cipro online no prescription in the usa: cipro – buy cipro online
http://nolvadex.life/# tamoxifen for men
tamoxifen citrate pct clomid nolvadex nolvadex generic
http://ciprofloxacin.tech/# buy cipro
buy cheap propecia prices buying cheap propecia price or get generic propecia online
https://maps.google.nu/url?sa=t&url=https://finasteride.store propecia price
buy cheap propecia without rx generic propecia pills and cost propecia no prescription cost generic propecia without insurance
buy cytotec online fast delivery: Cytotec 200mcg price – order cytotec online
https://lisinopril.network/# 20 mg lisinopril tablets
Cytotec 200mcg price: cytotec buy online usa – buy cytotec online
http://finasteride.store/# buy cheap propecia for sale
buy cipro online ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online
Buy Viagra online cheap: viagras.online – cheap viagra
http://viagras.online/# Viagra generic over the counter
Vardenafil online prescription Vardenafil online prescription Levitra online pharmacy
http://kamagra.win/# cheap kamagra
http://cialist.pro/# Tadalafil price
cialis for sale: Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription – Cialis over the counter
cheap kamagra: kamagra pills – buy Kamagra
Cialis 20mg price Generic Tadalafil 20mg price cheapest cialis
https://cialist.pro/# Buy Tadalafil 20mg
Buy Cialis online: Generic Tadalafil 20mg price – Buy Tadalafil 10mg
Cialis 20mg price cialis for sale or Cialis over the counter
http://images.google.com.bz/url?q=https://cialist.pro buy cialis pill
Cialis 20mg price in USA Buy Tadalafil 20mg and Generic Cialis price Buy Cialis online
https://cenforce.pro/# cheapest cenforce
buy Kamagra kamagra.win Kamagra 100mg
cialis generic: buy cialis online – Buy Tadalafil 10mg
Generic Levitra 20mg Levitra 10 mg buy online or Vardenafil online prescription
https://cse.google.com.gt/url?q=https://levitrav.store Levitra 20 mg for sale
п»їLevitra price Levitra 10 mg best price and Buy Vardenafil 20mg online Buy Vardenafil online
http://viagras.online/# Viagra generic over the counter
order cenforce: Purchase Cenforce Online – cheapest cenforce
https://viagras.online/# Buy Viagra online cheap
Generic Tadalafil 20mg price cialist.pro Generic Cialis price
Kamagra tablets buy Kamagra or п»їkamagra
http://www.choicesweepstakeslinks.com/link.php?url=https://kamagra.win cheap kamagra
Kamagra Oral Jelly buy Kamagra and Kamagra 100mg Kamagra tablets
Generic Viagra for sale: viagra without prescription – cheapest viagra
https://cialist.pro/# Cialis 20mg price
https://cenforce.pro/# buy cenforce
cenforce for sale Buy Cenforce 100mg Online cheapest cenforce
Buy Vardenafil 20mg: levitrav.store – Levitra generic best price
canada pharmacy online no prescription: canadian pharmacy online no prescription – no prescription canadian pharmacy
http://pharmworld.store/# online pharmacy discount code
https://pharmmexico.online/# mexican drugstore online
canadian prescription prices best online pharmacy that does not require a prescription in india canadian prescription
online pharmacy prescription: cheapest pharmacy – canadian pharmacy no prescription
rx pharmacy coupons: pharm world – canadian online pharmacy no prescription
mail order pharmacy india buy medicines online in india Online medicine order
http://pharmcanada.shop/# canadian pharmacy
thecanadianpharmacy: canadian pharmacy 24 – canadian online pharmacy
medicine in mexico pharmacies reputable mexican pharmacies online medication from mexico pharmacy
best online pharmacies in mexico: mexican pharmacy – medicine in mexico pharmacies
https://pharmworld.store/# canadian pharmacies not requiring prescription
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexico drug stores pharmacies – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
buy prescription drugs from canada cheap online canadian pharmacy review pharmacy wholesalers canada
online pharmacy prescription: pharm world store – online pharmacy non prescription drugs
https://pharmmexico.online/# mexican rx online
reputable indian online pharmacy reputable indian online pharmacy online pharmacy india
online pharmacy no prescriptions: canada drugs without prescription – buy pills without prescription
http://pharmcanada.shop/# pharmacy wholesalers canada
canadian pharmacy store my canadian pharmacy review or ordering drugs from canada
http://www.a-31.de/url?q=https://pharmcanada.shop reddit canadian pharmacy
buy canadian drugs canadian neighbor pharmacy and canadian drug stores canadian mail order pharmacy
canadian pharmacy world coupon legit non prescription pharmacies or rx pharmacy no prescription
https://www.google.hn/url?q=https://pharmworld.store canadian pharmacy coupon
reputable online pharmacy no prescription no prescription needed pharmacy and cheap pharmacy no prescription buying prescription drugs from canada
https://pharmcanada.shop/# legitimate canadian pharmacy online
online medication without prescription: buying prescription drugs from canada online – buy meds online without prescription
drugstore com online pharmacy prescription drugs pharm world best canadian pharmacy no prescription
https://pharmmexico.online/# mexican mail order pharmacies
best online pharmacy india: top 10 pharmacies in india – indianpharmacy com
doxycycline prices: order doxycycline – generic doxycycline
http://zithromaxa.store/# zithromax canadian pharmacy
20 mg prednisone tablet: buy prednisone 1 mg mexico – can i buy prednisone from canada without a script
prednisone 20 canadian online pharmacy prednisone prednisone 20mg tablets where to buy
prednisone 12 tablets price: canada buy prednisone online – prednisone 200 mg tablets
http://amoxila.pro/# can you buy amoxicillin over the counter in canada
neurontin brand name 800 mg: neurontin 2018 – neurontin 4 mg
zithromax 500mg can i buy zithromax over the counter zithromax 250 mg tablet price
1250 mg prednisone: prednisone 10 tablet – prednisone daily use
doxycycline hyc: buy doxycycline online – buy cheap doxycycline online
zithromax price canada: order zithromax over the counter – zithromax for sale cheap
buy zithromax canada: zithromax 500 mg lowest price drugstore online – zithromax antibiotic without prescription
buy doxycycline: doxycycline tablets – where to purchase doxycycline
http://gabapentinneurontin.pro/# neurontin cost in canada
prednisone where can i buy: prednisone without prescription medication – average cost of generic prednisone
https://doxycyclinea.online/# buy generic doxycycline
prednisone pills cost prednisone 200 mg tablets prednisone in uk
prednisone otc price: prednisone 500 mg tablet – buy prednisone 1 mg mexico
http://zithromaxa.store/# buy zithromax online with mastercard
zithromax online usa no prescription zithromax cost australia zithromax prescription
prednisone price australia: prednisone 20 mg pill – prednisone brand name us
price of prednisone tablets prednisone best price or prednisone 5 tablets
http://zanostroy.ru/go?url=http://prednisoned.online 1250 mg prednisone
cheapest prednisone no prescription 5 prednisone in mexico and buy prednisone online paypal buy prednisone 10mg online
zithromax over the counter: zithromax 500 tablet – zithromax antibiotic without prescription
amoxicillin no prescription amoxicillin generic or amoxicillin 500 mg cost
https://www.google.com.vn/url?q=https://amoxila.pro how to get amoxicillin
amoxicillin medicine amoxicillin discount coupon and amoxicillin 500 capsule where to get amoxicillin over the counter
http://prednisoned.online/# prednisone price
amoxicillin 500mg capsule cost: amoxicillin 500 mg for sale – amoxicillin 500 mg price
where to buy amoxicillin order amoxicillin 500mg medicine amoxicillin 500
neurontin capsule 400 mg neurontin 600mg or neurontin 100 mg capsule
https://www.google.nr/url?rct=j&url=https://gabapentinneurontin.pro medicine neurontin
brand name neurontin neurontin 800 mg price and cheap neurontin neurontin without prescription
prednisone 20 mg tablets coupon: prednisone 2 mg daily – prednisone 5 50mg tablet price
https://gabapentinneurontin.pro/# neurontin 100mg price
neurontin 1800 mg neurontin tablets no script gabapentin buy
generic zithromax over the counter: can you buy zithromax over the counter in canada – zithromax cost australia
https://amoxila.pro/# amoxicillin 500 mg brand name
doxycycline 100mg tablets: generic for doxycycline – how to buy doxycycline online
https://amoxila.pro/# generic amoxicillin
cost of neurontin 600 mg buy generic neurontin neurontin singapore
buy generic neurontin online: neurontin 100mg caps – purchase neurontin
how to buy amoxicillin online amoxil pharmacy or amoxicillin 500mg capsules uk
http://fotos24.org/url?q=https://amoxila.pro generic for amoxicillin
buy amoxicillin without prescription amoxicillin 500 mg tablet and amoxicillin 500mg capsules price amoxicillin over counter
drug neurontin 20 mg: canada neurontin 100mg discount – neurontin oral
online doxycycline doxycycline or doxycycline prices
https://images.google.sh/url?q=https://doxycyclinea.online how to buy doxycycline online
buy doxycycline online purchase doxycycline online and doxycycline hydrochloride 100mg doxycycline generic
prednisone 5mg price: how to purchase prednisone online – prednisone where can i buy
https://amoxila.pro/# buy amoxicillin canada
zithromax online paypal generic zithromax azithromycin buy zithromax online australia