Choosing between Early Decision II (ED II) and Regular Decision (RD) is one of the most important strategic choices Indian students make during US college admissions. With CBSE, ISC, and IB board exams overlapping January deadlines, understanding the advantages and risks of each plan becomes crucial. This guide breaks down ED II vs RD in simple terms—so you can make a confident, well-timed decision based on your goals, profile, and readiness. Here’s a clear, student-focused guide to help Indian applicants (CBSE, ISC, IB, and State Board students) make the right choice.
What is Early Decision II? How is it Different From ED I and RD?
Think of ED II as ED I with a later deadline.
- ED I: Early November deadlines, decisions in December.
- ED II: Early–mid January deadlines, decisions in February.
- RD: Early January deadlines, decisions in March/April.
The key rule: ED II is binding. If you get in, you must attend and withdraw all other applications.
Many selective colleges (UChicago, WashU, Tufts, NYU, Emory, Swarthmore, Wellesley, Bowdoin, Colby, etc.) offer ED II, but the Ivies do not.
Recommended Article: How to Strategize Your Regular Decision Applications (with January Deadlines)?
Why ED II Exists?
Colleges want to manage their yield—the percentage of admitted students who enroll. An ED II applicant is a guaranteed enrollee, which helps colleges plan better. That is why ED I and ED II pools often have higher acceptance rates than RD.
Even though ED II usually gives a smaller “boost” than ED I (because many seats are already taken), it still carries a meaningful admissions advantage over RD.
Read REA vs EA vs ED vs RD: Which College Application Plan Should You Choose?
Should You Apply ED II?
Here are the scenarios where ED II genuinely helps Indian students.
1. You Weren’t Ready for ED I (and Now Have Stronger Grades/Activities)
If your November timeline was packed with pre-boards, CAS deadlines (IB), or pending SAT testing, ED I might simply not have been feasible.
The January ED II deadline gives you:
- Better mid-year grades to show (important for CBSE/ISC students with strong Pre-Boards)
- Time to reflect on your Term exams or Internal Assessments (IB)
- Potentially improved SAT/ACT scores
- New leadership positions from school clubs, debate societies, MUNs, etc.
- Updated sports or extracurricular achievements from the first term
If your profile looks meaningfully stronger now than in November, ED II can be a smart strategic move.
2. You Have a Clear Second-Choice School You Truly Like
Maybe your ED I school didn’t work out—or maybe you didn’t apply ED I at all.
If there was another college you genuinely loved (say Tufts, NYU, or Claremont McKenna), and they offer ED II, this could be your best chance to:
- Show commitment
- Signal a higher yield likelihood
- Compete in a smaller, more self-selecting pool
For students who dreamed of two or three colleges but weren’t fully ready earlier, ED II gives you one more shot at signalling “You’re my first choice.”
3. You Are Financially Comfortable With a Binding Offer
In the US, ED applicants cannot compare financial aid packages across colleges.
Most Indian families applying for ED II fall into two camps:
- Those applying without needing aid
- Those who are comfortable with the estimate shown in the Net Price Calculator
If affordability is clear, ED II is straightforward.
If you absolutely need to compare aid, do NOT apply ED II. Choose RD!
You can appeal an ED package in case of major hardship, but this should not be your strategy.
When You Should NOT Apply ED II
1. You Have an RD School You Prefer More
This is the biggest mistake students make.
If you think you would be happier at an RD school (for example, Michigan, UIUC, UNC, Georgia Tech—none of which offer ED II), then binding yourself to an ED II school doesn’t make sense.
Remember: If you get in ED II, you will never know what could have happened in RD.
2. You’re Deferred from ED I and Still Have a Real Shot
If your ED I school deferred you and you strongly believe an updated mid-year transcript + strong LOCI can help, ED II becomes risky.
Because if you get accepted, ED II:
- You must withdraw your ED I application
- You will never get to see whether you would have been admitted ED I
If ED I was your dream school, think carefully.
3. You’re Rushing Last-Minute Supplements
ED II should not be a panic move.
If you are:
- Still drafting “Why this college?” essays
- Adding a school only because “it has ED II”
- Not ready with recommendation updates
- Struggling to finish while juggling board exam prep in January
Then RD is safer and may actually give you a better outcome.
Admissions officers will notice sloppy writing, generic answers, or lack of research.
4. Your Profile Isn’t Competitive Enough
The ED II boost helps only if you’re already within the college’s academic range.
Ask yourself:
- Does my GPA/Class Rank match their admitted student profile?
- Does my SAT/ACT fall within the middle 50%?
- Does my extracurricular profile align with their expectations?
If not, ED II won’t magically convert an unrealistic reach into an admit.
Be strategic, not emotional.
Special Note for Indian Students: January Deadlines + February–March Boards
Many CBSE/ISC students panic about ED II timing because ED II and RD deadlines overlap with Pre-Boards and Board Practical Exams.
A few tips:
Start essays before Pre-Boards: Your December and January schedules will only get busier.
- Ask teachers for recommendations early: Don’t wait until practical exams begin.
- Finish your Common App updates by the end of December: This includes activities, mid-year updates, and testing information.
- For IB students, include predicted grades: Your teachers can update predictions if your first-term performance was strong.
ED II vs Regular Decision: A Simple Comparison
| Factor | ED II | Regular Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Binding? | Yes | No |
| Deadline | Early–Mid January | Early–Mid January |
| Decision | Feb | March/April |
| Acceptance Rate Boost | Moderate | Lowest |
| Can Compare Aid? | No | Yes |
| Flexibility | Low | High |
| Useful For | Students with a clear first-choice in January | Students who want options or need aid |
| Risk | High (commitment) | Low |
So… Should You Apply ED II or RD?
A simple rule:
When to Choose ED II:
- You have a clear favourite that you’re truly willing to commit to.
- Your profile is competitive.
- You don’t need to compare financial aid.
- You’re not rushing essays and can submit your best work.
When to Choose RD:
- You want to keep multiple options open.
- You’re waiting for mid-year grades or exam results to strengthen your profile.
- You’re targeting universities that don’t offer ED II.
- You need financial aid comparisons.
Final Thoughts: Make ED II a Thoughtful Decision, Not a Backup Plan
ED II can significantly increase your chances—many Indian students gain admission to top colleges through this route. But the decision should be intentional, not impulsive.
Ask yourself:
“Will I be truly happy and comfortable committing to this college today?”
If the answer is yes, ED II might be your strongest move.
If not, RD gives you flexibility, time, and peace of mind as you balance board exams with the final stages of the admissions process.
Need Help with US College Applications?
If you’re still unsure which plan suits you best, explore how Inomi has guided hundreds of Indian students to top global universities – – – – visit our Testimonials page to learn more.
Ready for personalized guidance? Reach out through our Contact Us page, and our counsellors will help you build the right strategy for ED II, RD, or both.
About The Author
